How to Find Your Personal Style When You Like Everything

A colorful heap of clothes, including a hot-pink velour jacket, lime knitwear, and silver sequins, beside a kicked-off shoe on torn lavender paper.

Having personal style doesn’t mean committing to one aesthetic for the rest of your life. One day you’re convinced you’re a minimalist, the next you’re looking at a pair of shoes fit for a Bratz doll. Both can be true.

With so many aesthetics to obsess over, it’s easy to lose track of what you actually like and what Pinterest convinced you to like this week. So, how do you find your personal style when your taste is all over the place? Start by figuring out what you genuinely love, what you actually wear, and where the two meet.

Let’s get into it.

Start with three outfits you actually wear

Think of three outfits you’ve worn recently that you’d happily wear again. And don’t just pick the ones you took pictures of. The outfit you wore to dinner counts, but so does whatever you threw on to run errands. Sometimes the outfit we put the least thought into says the most about our style.

Now, think about what you liked about each one. And be specific! Maybe you love how your jacket looks with wide-leg jeans, or how a pair of red socks makes an otherwise boring outfit more interesting. Maybe you’ve finally found shoes that are cute and comfortable enough to wear all day. A rare achievement, my tight-fit archive knows.

While you’re at it, think about that one piece in your closet you absolutely love but somehow never wear. You know the one. Try styling it with something you already reach for regularly. Maybe that skirt you’ve been saving for a magical occasion just needs a pair of everyday boots. And if you still don’t wear it? That’s fine too. Not everything we love has to become part of our daily rotation.

There’s a reason you saved it

Go through your Pinterest boards or saved Instagram posts and pick five outfits that made you stop scrolling. Instead of obsessing over the entire look, figure out what caught your eye in the first place. Was it the sheer sleeves peeking out from under a blazer? The unexpected color combination? Or maybe a chunky shoe paired with a floral skirt?

Before you convince yourself you need an entirely new wardrobe, see if you can recreate that feeling with what you already own. Maybe you don’t need the exact lace top from the photo. A lacy camisole under your favorite jacket or a ruffled cuff peeking out of a sweater might do the trick. Sometimes it’s the ~tiniest~ details that make an outfit.

Take these three ASTR The Label tops, for example. One has feathery fringe at the hem, another brings the drama with its sleeves, and the third has a lace collar. Three completely different details, each capable of changing the mood of your usual jeans. Which one would you actually reach for?

Give your taste a working vocabulary

Now that you’ve looked at what you actually wear and what you keep saving, put the two side by side. Notice anything familiar? Maybe you have a thing for oversized jackets, tiny bags, or shoes that look slightly ridiculous in the best way. Maybe every outfit you save has some unexpected color combination. Whatever it is, chances are you’ve been gravitating toward the same details without even realizing it.

Try coming up with two or three words that describe your taste. And please, they don’t have to sound like something you’d read in a fashion magazine. “Boxy, shiny, and a little silly” is a perfectly valid description. So is “mostly comfortable with a touch of drama.” The idea is to give yourself something to work with the next time you’re staring into your closet wondering what to wear. Think of them as a starting point, not a set of rules.

Wear one piece three different ways

Pick a pair of pants you already love wearing and build three different outfits around them. Start by pairing them with your go-to shoes and see what works from there.

Chunky translucent lime-green Swarovski ring with a faceted pink center crystal and a halo of small clear crystals.
Swarovski made a Ring Pop. What was I supposed to do? Not buy it?

For the first outfit, try a fitted tee, sneakers, and a bright bag. Next, swap the tee for a dressy blouse, add some simple flats, and finish with tiny hoop earrings. For the third, throw on an oversized sweater, loafers, and that plastic ring you bought because it looked like candy (or maybe that’s just me?). Same pants, three completely different personalities. Which one feels the most like you? Even better, which one would you actually throw on when you’re running late?

You can try this with pretty much anything in your closet. A printed skirt, your favorite jacket, or the jeans you’ve worn approximately a thousand times. And if you don’t feel like changing your entire outfit, accessories can do a surprising amount of heavy lifting. A different bag, a belt, or even a little charm can change the whole mood.

Okay, but would you really wear it?

An outfit might look amazing in your bedroom mirror, but the real test is whether you still love it after spending an entire day in it. So, pick one of your new combinations and wear it somewhere. Run errands, meet a friend, go to work. Whatever makes sense for the outfit.

At the end of the day, think about what worked and what drove you crazy. Maybe you loved the skirt with flats but spent the entire day pulling your shirt down. Or maybe the outfit looked great but felt like it was missing something. A different top or a better accessory with a little oomph might be all it needs.

And take an outfit photo! Preferably a full-length one where you can actually see your shoes. Looking back at your outfits makes it easier to notice the little things, like whether you prefer a collared shirt open or buttoned up, or which proportions you keep coming back to. Plus, you’ll have your own little outfit archive for the next time you pull a “I have nothing to wear!”

Before you buy anything else…

After trying a few different outfits, you might start noticing what’s missing from your wardrobe. Maybe your favorite pants are too long for the shoes you usually wear, or every time you put on that one coat, it hides the best part of your outfit. Maybe you’ve got three tops that would look amazing with a bomber you don’t own. Now we’re getting somewhere.

Before you go shopping, though, see if you can make what you already own work. Sometimes a trip to the tailor or a little experimenting is all it takes. And when you do decide to buy something, be specific about what you’re looking for. There’s a big difference between needing a pair of straight-leg pants that work with your favorite pumps and deciding you’re suddenly going to become a completely different person who wears slacks every day.

I also have a rule to keep myself from buying things I’ll wear twice and forget about. Before buying something, I ask myself how many times I’ll realistically wear it. A top? At least 25 times. Shoes? 70. Jeans? 50. The numbers aren’t an exact science, but they make me think about whether something belongs in my wardrobe or if I’m just having a moment. I can love something without needing to own it.

What if your style keeps changing?

Well, of course it will! You’re allowed to change your mind about what you like. The clothes you were obsessed with two years ago might make you cringe today, and something you once swore you’d never wear could suddenly become your favorite thing. That’s half the fun of fashion.

Keep a little album of outfits you’ve worn and loved. Over time, you’ll probably notice that even when your taste changes, certain things stick around. Maybe you’re over bubble skirts, but you still love how crop tops look with wide-leg jeans. Or maybe you’ve moved on from bright colors but still can’t resist a unique texture. You can take the parts you love and bring them into whatever you’re wearing next.

And remember, finding your personal style isn’t about reaching some final version of yourself and calling it a day. You’re going to experiment, make questionable purchases, and occasionally look back at an outfit wondering what on earth you were thinking. Personally, I think that’s a lot more interesting than getting dressed the same way forever.

So, go wear something you love. Even if it makes absolutely no sense to anyone else.

Shopping encouragement, fashion investigations and other things your bank account specifically asked us not to send you.